Closed on a SoCal Home Care Agency With 100% Equity After a 21-Month Search: 9 Lessons for Other Searchers
Last month, we closed on Family Ties Home Care, a private-pay home care agency in Southern California, and I stepped in as CEO after a 21-month search. This community took my calls, pressure-tested my thinking and shared its scars. Here's my attempt to return the favor. Snapshot: • Business: Private-pay, non-medical home care agency in Southern California • Founders: A husband-and-wife team who are staying with the business and rolling equity • Search model: Committed capital / EIR, financed with 100% equity • Source: Buyside M&A firm, made possible by a friend I met in 2016 • Timeline: LOI signed in June, closed in October • My background: IB, Healthcare PE, Chicago Booth, then four years at TEAM Services Group (home care platform) as part of Alpine Investors' CEO-in-training program The founders started the business after the agency caring for one of their parents kept missing shifts and leaving the family in the dark. They built the agency they wished their family had found. That story is a major reason I wanted to partner with them. Here's what I'd pass along. 1. Pick the model that fits you Self-funded, traditional, committed capital and independent sponsor each come with different tradeoffs on economics, support and speed. I chose a committed capital, executive-in-residence (EIR) style partnership, and I think more experienced operators should look hard at it. Why it works for the entrepreneur: You simplify the fundraise. Instead of raising a search fund up front and syndicating equity after the LOI, you build conviction with one committed partner. Your capital partner works with you weekly, from thesis building through sourcing, negotiation, diligence and into operations. You keep the autonomy of a traditional search with the depth of an institutional partner. And when a founder asks whether you can close, you can answer with certainty and honesty. Why it works for investors: They get searchers with operating experience and a right to win in a specific space, plus the opportunity to write a bigger check behind something they have conviction in. There are diminishing returns to diversification, and spreading across too many investments inevitably breaks the promise of what has made ETA so special: mentorship from investor to entrepreneur. NCL Partners delivered on that consistently. Lesson: Be clear-eyed about your situation, risk appetite, operating willingness, and incentive structure before you choose. The right model is the one that fits what you are trying to solve for. 2. Finance for the hold, not the close We financed the deal with 100% equity. That's unusual in search, so here's why. This is a growth investment, and we didn't want to be constrained by leverage. The day after close is when you know the least about the business over the entire hold period. Why put yourself in a vulnerable position by levering up at that exact moment? This isn't a diversified portfolio. It's a concentrated bet. Know what game you are playing. You can always raise debt once you've mastered the business. All-equity was also a better litmus test in underwriting: the deal had to stand on its own merits, with no financial engineering gymnastics. Lesson: Structure your capital for the hold period, not the closing table. Debt can come later, once you've earned the right to it. 3. Know where you have a right to win I spent four years operating in home care before I launched my search, so I centered all my sourcing on personalized care. Service types and ICPs varied, but the theme never did. That focus made me credible with founders because I knew the questions that mattered. Lesson: Focus on spaces where your background gives you a real edge. Then raise from investors who believe in that space and see you as a force multiplier in it. Alignment upfront saves a lot of friction later. 4. Be the most enthusiastic, optimistic networker you know This deal traces back toredactedI was a 25-year-old PE associate when an early search investor made time to meet with me about ETA. That same year, I met a fellow alum's parent at an alumni luncheon in Chicago. I knew it was a relationship worth keeping warm. Years later, early in my search, he suggested I meet an intermediary he knew. That intermediary introduced me to the founders. Lesson: You never know when you're one degree of separation from a game-changing connection. Keep relationships warm long before you need them. 5. Get creative with sourcing I ran a long list of direct sourcing efforts with founders, supported by the usual data and outreach tools. But everyone has the same databases and AI tools now. My deal ultimately came through a relationship. Before reaching out to my tier 1 targets, I got in front of their customers first. I was hunting for positive stories from raving fans of the service. Those stories told me which businesses were worth pursuing before I ever contacted a founder. Hot take: the most meaningful funnel metric in search isn't outreach, replies, meetings or LOIs. It's second meetings in person. Are both sides investing more time based on meeting one, and willing to physically get together? That's the signal worth tracking. I built my outreach on the principles of Unreasonable Hospitality, aiming to give more than expected to every founder and every contact who might lead me to a great deal. Treat the people around a deal with the same care you give the seller. Lesson: Ask yourself what AI can't do. Warm intros, showing up in person and earning trust in a local community are where the edge is. And get in front of customers before you approach your top targets. 6. Don't rush to LOI This is not the same game as PE. When I met the founders in person, I brought a handwritten note about why their story stayed with me and what we had in common. That trust carried us through diligence, the tough conversations and now the transition. Lesson: Spend meaningful time building a relationship with the seller before you negotiate. You're asking them to hand you their life's work, and you're evaluating them as a trusted partner. 7. Hire quality advisors, and balance discipline with a bias to action Strong QoE, tax and legal advisors pay for themselves. The hardest part of my search was getting close and walking away more than once, even after real time, money or both had gone into a deal. Stay in tune with the balancing act between the patience and discipline the search requires and a bias to action once you have something good on your hands. There are no perfect deals in the lower middle market, but there are plenty of poor ones. Lesson: Don't skimp on diligence, and listen when it tells you to walk. Don't fall victim to the sunk cost fallacy. This one was worth the wait. 8. Run a tight process that keeps all stakeholders accountable Between LOI and close, you're coordinating sellers, investors, QoE, tax and legal advisors, each with their own priorities. Deals lose momentum when no one owns the timeline. I kept a shared tracker with clear owners and dates for every workstream and held each party to it, myself included. Lesson: Momentum is fragile. As the searcher, you own the process, so make accountability visible to everyone involved. 9. When you close, celebrate! The search is a grind. We marked the close with a dinner with the founders, and I gave them a gift that was a bookend to the one that started our relationship. They gifted me something pretty sweet too! Lesson: Take a moment with the people who got you there before diving into the operating phase. A few final thoughts: I've come to believe good fortune grows from three seeds: positioning, optimism, and action. This means putting yourself in situations where you can attract luck and build deep, authentic, meaningful relationships along the way. Don't go fast too early. Build the foundation of your network and get low-stakes reps in. It's not a race. It's about being ready to pounce when the right opportunity strikes. Brad Stulberg said, "Caring deeply is the cost of admission for a deep and textured life." I'd say it's also the cost of admission for a fulfilling search. Humanize the process at every turn. My focus now is getting my arms around operations, supporting the team and caregivers who make this business what it is, and preparing us for accelerated growth. Our job is to earn the trust families place in us and live by three simple words: Care the Most. Thank you to the founders for letting me carry forward what they built, and to my investors for their unwavering support. Thank you to my mentors for teaching me how to lead, and to the searchers and operators who went far beyond. To my wife and our daughters: thank you for your patience, belief and unconditional love, especially on the tough days. My door will always be open to the next entrepreneur, the way so many have been for me. What a challenging and rewarding ride it has been! Questions on any of the above? Drop them in the comments. I'm happy to answer.