My 30-Minute CIM Screen, Rerun for the October 1 SBA Changes
In May, I posted the 30-minute screen I run on every CIM before I build a model. Since the SBA rules changed on October 1, part of it lets through deals a lender would now turn down. This is the version I use now. - Revenue quality: mostly the same A top customer over 25% with no multi-year contract still lowers my ceiling. One thing I'd add now: project revenue from the same B2B clients every year behaves a lot like recurring revenue. So I look for repeat project clients before I close a CIM that has no contracts. - Owner dependency: there is a clock on it After an SBA-financed acquisition, the seller can't stay on as an owner or an employee. They can stay as a consultant, for 24 months at most. So the question is no longer only "does this run without the owner?" It is "can every relationship the owner holds move to me inside two years?" - EBITDA to cash: the step that changed the most My old check was adjusted EBITDA, minus what I would pay a GM, minus a rough tax number, against SBA debt service at a conservative growth assumption. The lender's check now: 1. Earnings are the last fiscal year or the average of the last two. Not trailing twelve, and no growth. The lender can look at projections but can't rely on them. 2. The GM salary still comes out. 3. Debt service includes the seller note. If the note is interest-only and not on full standby, it is tested as if it amortized over no more than 10 years. 4. The bar for an acquisition is 1.25x. I took the tax line out of the pass/fail. Some lenders don't take income tax off a pass-through and expect the owner's draw to cover it. That is lender practice, not an SBA rule, so I still check separately that what is left covers my taxes and my own bills. - New step: the $3M line If the price is $3M or more, not counting any real estate, the lender has to get a Quality of Earnings report, and the coverage test uses the QoE's earnings, not the broker's. For a CIM at that size I screen on the add-backs I would expect a QoE to keep. The report can be financed, and what you pay for it yourself can count toward your injection. - What I am deciding in 30 minutes: the same Still not whether the deal is good. Just whether it is worth 4 hours of my time to find out. The difference is that a deal that looks comfortable on trailing numbers can miss 1.25x on last year's, and I would rather find that out in minute 25 than after the LOI. Lenders here: on a CIM under $3M, where no QoE is required, how hard do you push on the broker's add-backs before you look at coverage?