Should a Seller Get a Sell-Side Quality of Earnings?
A sell-side quality of earnings is the seller testing its own earnings before a buyer does. Done early, it lets the seller choose when problems surface and how they are explained. It does not stop the buyer from checking, and it does not promise a price. redactedKey Insight A sell-side quality of earnings is a QoE the seller commissions, usually from an independent accounting firm, before or during marketing. It tests the same kinds of things a buyer's QoE tests, earlier, and it reports to the seller first. The case for it rests on what breaks deals once a buyer starts checking. In Axial's Dead Deal Reports, QoE EBITDA discrepancies were 21.3% of broken LOIs inredactedof 75), up from 10.6% inredactedof 47). Diligence findings combined, QoE and non-QoE, were 46.7% of broken LOIs inredactedof 75). These are shares of deals that broke, not failure rates, from lower middle market deals on one platform, in small samples. They do not show that a sell-side QoE would have saved any of those deals. The short answer: Sometimes, and the call is a judgment rather than a rule. A sell-side QoE tends to earn its place when the add-backs are complex, the books are messy, there are several entities or locations, or a larger business is being sold through a competitive process. It tends to matter less for a small deal on clean, simple books. It will not replace the buyer's diligence or guarantee a price. What it buys is timing: the seller finds the problems first, while there is still room to fix, document or disclose them. Continue reading ...