Thoughts on paying above market multiple on acquisition?

searcher profile

February 05, 2024

by a searcher from Miami University of Ohio in Lexington, KY, USA

Some color to my situation... It is in an industry I have experience. I'm geographically constrained and this is in my radius. Clean financials with strong reputation and past performance. It is a competitive situation. Seller chose me over 3 other parties even though I wasn't the highest offer. DSCR is 1.5 at current sale price. SBA has approved.

What are the long term implications of "overpaying" for a business that I should be aware of that my blinders are keeping me from seeing?

1
30
338
Replies
30
commentor profile
Reply by a searcher
from University of California, Berkeley in San Francisco, CA, USA
One thing no one has mentioned is the overall situation... I'm also location constrained. To find a business in your wheelhouse, so close to you, and at a "reasonable" DSCR is hard to find. "Multiple" is not the factor that I would concern myself with. What I would worry about with respect to the price is how comfortable you are with reasonable/likely downside scenarios. It sounds like you've flexed this deal pretty good in your models, and you're comfortable.


I walked from a deal on Christmas eve— similar to your situation in many ways. Weird situation where we weren't under LOI, but where we were essentially in diligence. We couldn't get to a final agreement on price. I kept trying to bring them to my position based on multiple. My analysis of downside situations made me uncomfortable at the price they were asking. I was willing to stretch up some because of the circumstance, but not to what they wanted.


I think one thing I could have done to get the deal done would have been to shift the conversation from multiple to showing them the downside scenarios I was looking at. Maybe I could have brought them around if they could have seen the risks with the customer concentration and my concern about the downside better.
commentor profile
Reply by a lender
from Eastern Illinois University in 900 E Diehl Rd, Naperville, IL 60563, USA
First off, congratulations on securing an opportunity. If the DSCR is over 1.50x, it does not sound like you are necessarily over-paying from a cash flow perspective, especially if you are doing an SBA deal, unless there is a lot of seller debt on standby. We see many deals getting done with SBA financing with the DSCR much closer to 1.25x.

If I were in your shoes, I would want to be sure I was confident the business would have the sustained ability to repay the debt. Also, is there an opportunity to grow the business. If both of these items exist, again you may not be over-paying but you may be paying at the upper end of the market for this particular business. You need to look at what value you can bring and if that value in the future and your potential earnings from the business would exceed what you are paying.

Usually the biggest issue with over-paying is stressing the business cash flow. So long as you are not doing that you can make a deal work. Still not saying it is ideal, but usually a business is valued based on what someone is willing to pay for it. If there were others willing to pay close to that much, then the business might have that value. I hope this helps. Just my thoughts.
commentor profile
+28 more replies.
Join the discussion