Your Replacement-Salary Add-Back Prices the Owner at 17%. The Evidence Says 83%.
Adding back an under-market owner salary net of a manager's cost is the standard adjustment. It prices a job description, and the tax data says a job description is not what leaves.redactedKey Insight A replacement-salary add-back adds an under-market owner salary back into earnings and deducts what a professional manager would cost. On $1.2M of EBITDA with a $200,000 replacement manager it marks the owner down by roughly 17%. Two natural experiments on tax records covering about eleven million firms measured what actually happens when the owner leaves: profit fell 82% after premature death and 83% after retirement, where retirement means the owner stepped back and handed operations to a hired manager, which is precisely the substitution the adjustment assumes will work. The two methods differ by close to an order of magnitude on the same person. The reason is structural rather than careless: a replacement salary prices a role, and roles are the only component with an observable market price, while what departs also includes personally held customer relationships, supplier terms extended on tenure, undocumented pricing judgment, staff retention attached to the individual and credit relationships. None of those carries a salary line, so a schedule built from the payroll register cannot see them. The adjustment is better understood as a floor than as an estimate. The Context The standard owner adjustment is a hypothesis presented as a measurement. This piece covers: The arithmetic gap: 17% against 82 to 83%, on the same owner. Why the method persists: three reasons, none of them incompetence. What to do instead: test the hypothesis in diligence rather than asserting it in a schedule. Continue reading ....